The 5 Greatest Button Mushroom Substitutes

Rate this post

Mushrooms are high in nutrients and are available fresh or tinned.

There are many various types of mushrooms, but the most common is the button mushroom, which is roughly the size of a silver dollar.

The taste of button mushrooms is light, and the texture is smooth.

They are commonly accessible in supermarkets, making them a simple option for chefs searching for a healthful item to include in their dishes.

Nevertheless, utilizing button mushrooms in recipes has significant drawbacks.

For one thing, they may be costly. Also, they might be difficult to locate in certain sections of the nation.

Fortunately, numerous different varieties of mushrooms may be used as button mushroom alternatives in recipes.

We’ll go through five of the greatest choices in this post.

What exactly is a button mushroom?

The button mushroom is one of the world’s most popular mushrooms.

The mushroom is a little white mushroom with a spherical crown and a slender stem.

Button mushrooms are soft and firm, and may be eaten raw or cooked.

These mushrooms are cultivated in controlled settings and are available all year.

The White Button, a member of the Agaricus family, is the most common kind of button mushroom.

Button mushrooms have a light taste and scent that has been likened to citrus, nutmeg, and cinnamon.

They are typically used in salads, but they may also be found in soups, pasta meals, and stir-fry foods.

The 5 Greatest Button Mushroom Substitutes

If you are attempting to reduce your meat consumption or do not have access to button mushrooms, there are numerous excellent replacements.

These are the top five button mushroom substitutes.

Cremini Mushrooms 1

Cremini mushrooms, commonly known as Baby Bellas, are a tasty alternative to button mushrooms.

Cremini mushrooms taste similar to button mushrooms and may be eaten raw or cooked.

These mushrooms grow in clusters and have firm white gills that run along the stem of the mushroom.

Its stems are thicker than typical button stems.

Cremini mushrooms may be found throughout North America and Europe.

They were found in Italy, but were given the name Crimini to celebrate their cultivation in Cremona.

These mushrooms are often dark chestnut brown on the exterior and pristine white on the interior.

2 stuffed portobello mushrooms

Portobello mushrooms are an excellent replacement for button mushrooms.

They are dark brown or black on the surface, with immaculate white flesh on the inside.

These mushrooms are enormous.

Most portobellos have an open top that exposes the gills beneath and are four to six inches in diameter.

Portobello mushrooms are a kind of Agaricus bisporus that has been developed.

The portobello mushroom is indigenous to North America, Europe, and Asia.

They may be roasted or grilled for added taste and a crisp texture.

Three Shiitake Mushrooms

Shiitake mushrooms taste similar to button mushrooms.

They may also be eaten raw or cooked.

Their taste and fragrance are reminiscent of chestnuts and cinnamon.

Shiitakes have also been characterized as having a meaty mouthfeel.

Shiitake mushrooms are very popular in East Asia.

This specific mushroom has been consumed for over 3000 years.

The taste and color of the mushrooms are affected by the kind of wood on which they are cultivated.

Shiitakes may also be purchased dry and must be reconstituted in hot water for 20 minutes before use.

Oyster Mushrooms 4

Oyster mushrooms may be used in place of button mushrooms.

They have a nice texture and go well with soups and stir-fry recipes, particularly when coupled with tofu.

These mushrooms form clusters and are long and slender.

The hue of oyster mushrooms ranges from mild to dark beige, yellowish-white, or grayish-blue.

Oyster mushrooms have been likened to abalone, lobster, chicken, and even beef in terms of taste.

Oyster mushrooms originated in Asia but are now popular worldwide due to their ability to thrive in temperate conditions.

5 Mushrooms, White

White mushrooms are closely related to button mushrooms.

They are popular in stir fry meals and may be eaten raw or cooked.

The crisp white meat of these mushrooms is ideal for slicing into salads or adding to pasta recipes.

White mushrooms complement tofu well as well.

The mushrooms grow in groups and have closed caps.

Cooler areas, such as Canada, Northern Europe, Alaska, and Northern China, are ideal for growing these mushrooms.

White mushrooms and button mushrooms are closely related.

Since these two mushrooms have comparable qualities, they may be exchanged for one another without sacrificing taste or texture.


Button mushrooms are a common ingredient in a variety of recipes.

These are, however, not the only edible mushrooms available.

There are various excellent button mushroom replacements available.

Cremini, Portobello, Shiitake, Oyster, and White mushrooms are the finest button mushroom replacements.

These mushrooms not only replace button mushrooms, but they also add taste and texture to your cuisine.

You’ll never have to miss out on excellent tastes and textures again if you have any of these five fantastic alternatives to button mushrooms on hand at the grocery store or farmers market.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *