The 5 Greatest Anchovy Paste Substitutes

Rate this post

Have you ever seen anchovy paste mentioned as an ingredient in a recipe and wondered, “What the heck is anchovy paste?”

Or maybe you saw it at the grocery store and pondered what you would do with it if you purchased it.

Now you can stop wondering.

In this post, we’ll cover all you need to know about anchovy paste, including what it is, how to use it, and some great dishes that use this unusual ingredient.

We’ll also offer some of our favorite anchovy paste substitutions in case you can’t locate them at your local grocery shop.

Thus, whether you’re an inquisitive cook looking to learn more about this umami-packed ingredient or a home chef looking for a new taste profile for your next dish, keep reading to find out all you need to know about anchovy paste.

What is Anchovy Paste?

Anchovies are tiny, oily fish that are often used in cooking as a flavour element.

Although fresh anchovies may be eaten whole, canned or preserved anchovies are more usually available.

Grinding anchovies into a thick, spreadable paste yields anchovy paste.

It has a pungent, salty taste and is often used as a condiment or spice.

Anchovy paste may be used to flavor sauces, salads, marinades, pizza toppings, and other meals.

It’s also a popular addition to Caesar salad dressing.

Although anchovy paste is widely available in supermarkets, it may also be prepared at home with a few basic ingredients.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Anchovy Paste

If you dislike the taste or odor of anchovies, there are several replacements that will give your meal the same umami flavor.

These are the top five anchovy paste substitutes:

1 – Anchovy Fillets

Anchovies are tiny, oily fish that are often used in cooking as a flavour element.

Although anchovies are not everyone’s favorite ingredient, they may lend a depth of flavor to meals that is difficult to replicate with other components.

Anchovy fillets are a typical kind of anchovies that may be purchased canned or jarred in most supermarkets.

It is essential to drain and rinse anchovy fillets before adding them to your meal.

This will aid in the removal of excess salt and oil from the fish.

Anchovies may be used in a variety of cuisines, such as pasta sauces, pizza toppings, and salads.

Consider using anchovy fillets to enhance the taste of your dish.

2 – Fish Sauce

In many Asian nations, fish sauce is a popular condiment.

It is prepared by fermenting fish or shellfish for many months in sea water.

The liquid that results is then filtered and bottled.

Fish sauce has a strong, pungent taste that is often used in recipes to enhance savory umami elements.

It’s a staple in many Southeast Asian dishes, including Thai, Vietnamese, and Cambodian.

Fish sauce may be used as a dipping sauce, marinade, or as a flavoring agent in soups or stir-fries.

Although the taste of fish sauce may take some getting used to for people who aren’t used to it, it’s a fantastic way to add depth and complexity to any meal.

3 – Worcestershire Sauce

Worcestershire sauce adds flavor to a variety of recipes, but have you ever pondered what gives it its particular flavor? Vinegar, tamarind, soy sauce, garlic, onion, and chili peppers are among the components in the sauce.

These components are mixed together and fermented for up to two years.

At this period, the components combine to form the distinct flavor of Worcestershire sauce.

Although the sauce’s actual origins are uncertain, it is said to have been produced in the nineteenth century by two English chemists attempting to imitate a famous Indian spice.

Worcestershire sauce is now appreciated all throughout the globe, and it remains an important element in many renowned meals.

4 – Capers

Capers are the unopened flower buds of the Capparis spinosa, a low-growing Mediterranean shrub.

For ages, the plant has been utilized as food and medicinal, and its blooms have been used to produce aperitifs and fragrances.

Capers are picked in the spring and early summer, when the buds are still sensitive and new.

They are then pickled in vinegar or brine to retain their taste.

Capers have a tart, acidic taste that is often used to give depth to meals like pizza and spaghetti sauce.

They may also be used as a garnish or as an ingredient in salads.

5 – Chopped Kalamata Olives

Chopped Kalamata olives are a tasty and nutritious way to add flavor to any recipe.

The olives are plucked before being sliced into little bits.

This guarantees that each mouthful is flavorful.

In addition to adding taste, chopped Kalamata olives are a wonderful source of healthful fats and antioxidants.

They may be used in a variety of cuisines, including salads, spaghetti, and pizza.

Chopped Kalamata olives are a terrific alternative whether you’re searching for a healthy approach to enhance flavor or simply want to try something different.


Finally, a few other anchovy paste replacements may be employed in a hurry.

Although not as powerful in flavor, they may still provide a good depth of savory flavor to your food.

It all depends on what you’re searching for and what you have on hand when it comes to choosing an appropriate alternative.

Experimenting is essential for finding the best match for your requirements.

Do you have a favorite anchovy paste replacement? Leave your opinions in the comments section below.


What can I sub for anchovy paste in Caesar salad?

Worcestershire sauce includes anchovies, so it’s a good substitute if you can’t obtain anchovy paste.

How do I substitute fish sauce for anchovy paste?

Per anchovy fillet, use 2 teaspoons fish sauce. Hence, in dishes where anchovies are used to enhance taste, feel free to substitute 1 anchovy.

What is a vegetarian substitute for anchovies?

We hit on a strong combination after some experimenting: miso combined with ground toasted nori (toasting brings up the nutty taste of the seaweed). Miso is high in glutamates, whereas nori contains both glutamates and ribonucleotides (including some of the same ones that are in anchovies).

What can I substitute for 1 tablespoon of anchovy paste?

Soy sauce has a much more liquid texture than anchovy paste, but it has a comparable taste and amount of saltiness. If you’re only looking for a taste boost, soy sauce is a wonderful replacement.

What is anchovy paste equivalent to?

2 tsp. anchovy paste (to make your own quick anchovy paste, simply mash anchovies to a paste consistency)
1 teaspoon anchovy paste = 1 teaspoon mashed anchovies (but remember the paste has added vinegar and spices and is milder in flavor)
Further details…•August 19, 2019
Measurements, Equivalents, and Substitutions
1 fillet anchovy = 1

Why is anchovy paste being discontinued?

Pioneer will no longer produce Pecks Anchovette and Redro fish pastes. According to the corporation, customers are no longer interested in minced fish kept in a jar. With its worldwide network, Pecks may yet find a way back into the country, but Redro’s time in the country is certainly over.

What does anchovy paste do in a recipe?

Nonetheless, the danger of overpowering your meal, as entire anchovies may, is limited since anchovy paste doesn’t make your food taste too fishy. Instead, it adds depth to the taste, enhancing the attributes of the other components.

Why is there no more anchovy paste?

According to a Pioneer representative, the business decided to discontinue production of the fish paste products at the end of last year as part of a “ongoing portfolio assessment.”

What can I use instead of anchovy paste Reddit?

Cooking. Pro tip: fish sauce may be used in place of anchovy filets or paste in Caesar dressing.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *