The 5 Best Substitutes for Yellow Mustard

5/5 - (2 votes)

Take a moment to think about the sandwich that you enjoy eating the most.

Is it grilled cheese made with American cheese and mustard in the yellow color? Would you like your BLT with mayonnaise and yellow mustard? Would you like honey mustard and yellow mustard on your turkey club? No matter what it is, you probably can’t picture yourself eating it without the accompaniment of yellow mustard.

The question is, what exactly is yellow mustard, and how did it come to be such a common condiment? In addition, what are the best alternatives to yellow mustard that can give your sandwich the same flavor profile and still be used in its place?

What is Yellow Mustard?

Yellow mustard has a flavor that is unmistakable and is familiar to anyone who has ever consumed a hot dog or potato salad.

But what precisely is this condiment, and where did it first make its appearance?

Yellow mustard is a type of prepared mustard that is typically crafted by combining ground mustard seeds, vinegar, water, and various spices. Its name comes from the color of the mustard it produces.

The mustard seeds are to blame for the dish’s signature tangy taste, while the vinegar and spices are responsible for adding depth and dimension to the dish.

The specific components and proportions can differ from one brand to the next, but the majority of commercially available varieties contain turmeric, which is responsible for their signature bright yellow color.

In spite of the fact that yellow mustard is now widely available in the United States, its origins can be traced back to Europe.

The earliest versions were most likely made with wine or verjuice rather than vinegar, and their primary function was likely as a medicinal remedy rather than as a food item.

Not until the 19th century did mass production of mustard begin, and it was not until much later that it was sold commercially.

In the beginning, its primary function was that of an ingredient in other dishes, such as vinaigrette and deviled eggs, among other things.

But by the beginning of the 20th century, it had developed into a widespread condiment used on sandwiches and other straightforward fare.

Today, yellow mustard is one of the condiments that is used all over the world the most frequently.

Its sharp taste goes well with savory foods like hot dogs and hamburgers, but it can also add a touch of brightness to salads or vegetables that have been roasted in the oven.

In addition, as a result of its adaptability, yellow mustard is an essential component of a great deal of culinary favorites.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Yellow Mustard

If you’re out of yellow mustard and need a substitution for a recipe, try one of these five substitutes.

1 – Dijon Mustard

The mustard known as Dijon mustard gets its name from the city of Dijon in France, where it was first developed.

It is traditionally prepared with brown or black mustard seeds, vinegar, and wine, and it has a flavor that is both pungent and sour.

Although the consistency of Dijon mustard can shift slightly from brand to brand, the condiment is typically silky and creamy.

Be aware that the flavor will become somewhat more nuanced if you replace yellow mustard with Dijon mustard in a given recipe. This is something to keep in mind when making the switch.

Yellow mustard is milder in flavor and has a hint of sweetness, whereas Dijon mustard has a more sour taste and more of a kick to it.

On the other hand, either mustard can be used in a wide variety of recipes, including chicken salad and deviled eggs, for example.

Mustard from the Dijon region of France is renowned for its complex flavor as well as its adaptability, making it an indispensable ingredient in any kitchen.

2 – Brown Mustard

Brown mustard is a type of mustard seed that differs from the more common yellow mustard seed in that it is more pungent and comes in a smaller size.

It has a flavor that is sharp and pungent, and it is frequently used in pickling recipes.

The seeds of brown mustard can also be ground into a powder and utilized as a seasoning rub for various types of meat.

When brown mustard is used in place of yellow mustard, it is important to reduce the amount used because brown mustard has a stronger flavor.

It is possible that a small amount of sugar or honey will be required to counteract the heat.

In general, brown mustard is an excellent way to add some additional flavor to the foods you prepare.

3 – Honey Mustard

A type of salad dressing known as honey mustard is created by combining honey and mustard.

It enjoys a lot of popularity in countries such as the United States of America, Canada, and the United Kingdom.

Honey mustard has a distinct flavor that varies depending on the proportion of honey to mustard that is used, but it is typically sweet and spicy at the same time.

The consistency is dense and velvety, very much like mayonnaise in appearance.

In many recipes, yellow mustard can be replaced with honey mustard instead. Honey mustard is an alternative to yellow mustard.

It is frequently utilized in the preparation of sandwiches, as a coating for ham or fish, as well as a dip for chicken or pork.

Honey mustard is a popular condiment that is frequently used in salads as well as coleslaw.

Instead of using vinaigrette, try using honey mustard dressing for a flavor that is more on the sweet side.

It is also possible to make a marinade out of it, which can be used for roasting or grilling meat.

4 – Spicy Mustard

There is a variety of mustard known as spicy mustard, which is made by preparing regular mustard with the addition of chili peppers or other spices.

The flavor can range from being very mild to being extremely hot, and the color can be anywhere from bright yellow to deep brown.

Although most brands of spicy mustard have a smooth consistency, some varieties may contain whole mustard seeds or bits of chili pepper.

In many different recipes, yellow mustard can be replaced with spicy mustard for a unique flavor.

Sandwiches, burgers, hot dogs, and even potato salad can get an interesting new flavor from using this ingredient.

Try substituting spicy mustard for either ketchup or mayonnaise for a dish that you want to have a more robust flavor profile for.

Just make sure you give the dish a taste test before you serve it because the level of spiciness in different brands can vary greatly.

5 – Wasabi

Wasabi is a delicious condiment that has its roots in Japanese cuisine.

It stands out from other condiments because to its one-of-a-kind flavor and velvety consistency.

Because it has a spicy taste profile that is comparable to that of yellow mustard, wasabi is often used in its place.

Wasabi, on the other hand, has a heat level that is noticeably higher than that of mustard, making it an excellent choice for those who like a bit of kick in their meals.

Wasabi is known for having a spicy flavor, but it also has a creamy consistency, which makes it an excellent choice for use as a spread on sandwiches or as a dipping sauce.

Wasabi is sure to give your next meal an extra kick, whether you consume it on its own or use it in place of mustard.


In conclusion, yellow mustard is an excellent condiment with a flavor that is adaptable and can be utilized in a wide variety of dishes.

Try one of the following mustards if you are looking for an alternative to yellow mustard: Dijon mustard, brown mustard, honey mustard, spicy mustard, or wasabi mustard.

Your dish will take on the flavor of whichever of these condiments you decide to use, so make sure to pick the one that appeals to your palette the most.


What can I use instead of yellow mustard?

Try substituting an equal amount of mayonnaise for the yellow mustard. This will not provide you with the same flavor, but it will keep the consistency the same. Use a small amount of prepared horseradish or wasabi in place of the horseradish when making Dijon Mustard or Spicy Brown Mustard.

What can be used instead of mustard?

Turmeric, Wasabi Powder, and Horseradish are Some Alternatives That Can Be Used Instead.

Turmeric, on the other hand, is not nearly as fiery as mustard, so you won’t need to worry about your dish becoming overly spicy as a result of using it. Wasabi Powder Because wasabi is hotter than mustard, you should begin with one-half the amount called for in the recipe and give it a taste before adding more.

What has similar taste to mustard?

Because horseradish and mustard come from the same plant family, it stands to reason that the two have flavor profiles that are comparable. Both horseradish and dry mustard can add heat to dishes, but horseradish is typically more potent than dry mustard, so use less of it than the recipe calls for and adjust it based on how it tastes. When you’re out of other dry spices, you can fall back on turmeric as a reliable substitute.

What mustard is closest to yellow mustard?

Mustard yellow in color.

Yellow mustard is the best alternative to Dijon mustard, followed by brown mustard. Both of these are excellent substitutes for one another because they are so comparable. Mustard powder made from white mustard seeds and colored with turmeric is called yellow mustard. In comparison to yellow mustard, which has a more subdued flavor, the mustard from Dijon has a more sour and piquant flavor.

What gives yellow mustard its flavor?

The bright yellow color of yellow mustard comes from turmeric, which is combined with yellow mustard seeds, vinegar, and water (and possibly some additional spices) to make a thick, squeezeable sauce. Turmeric is also responsible for the mustard’s characteristic flavor. Yellow mustard has a flavor that is sharp, sour, and tangy, but it is not particularly spicy and won’t help anyone clear their sinuses.