The 5 Best Substitutes for Half and Half

5/5 - (1 vote)

Why is it so difficult to locate Half and Half these days? Despite the fact that it is one of the most adaptable ingredients in the kitchen, it seems as if the grocery shop in my neighborhood is always out of it whenever I need it.

Milk and cream are both components of the beverage known as “half and half.”

It’s used in everything from coffee to baking, but it’s also a wonderful complement to savory recipes like stews and casseroles.

But what should you do if you go to the shop and they are out of both half and half and whole milk?

Depending on what you need it for, there are a few different options that may serve as suitable replacements in a situation.

You may add either milk or heavy cream with your coffee.

When you are baking, you may combine milk and butter in proportions that are equal to each other.

In addition, sour cream or plain yogurt may be used as an acceptable alternative in savory dishes.

It should come as no surprise that fresh milk and cream are always going to be the beverages that can most successfully stand in for half and half.

However, if you are unable to locate it either, the options provided here should be sufficient.

What is Half and Half?

A dairy product known as “half and half” is created by combining milk and cream in an equal proportion.

It is included into a wide variety of dishes, the most common of which being soups, sauces, and baked products.

Additionally, you may use it as a creamer for your coffee.

Half and Half may trace its roots back to the United Kingdom, where it was once sold under the name “half cream.”

In 1884, the phrase “half and half” was used for the first time that can be documented in the United States.

Half and Half has a thick, creamy consistency, with a flavor that is just slightly sweet.

It is often offered for sale in containers of a pint’s capacity.

Half and Half has a shelf life of around two weeks if it is kept in the refrigerator.

After it has been opened, it should be consumed within the next week.

There is a maximum shelf life of six months for frozen Half and Half.

Put the container of frozen food into the refrigerator for the night so it may defrost.

Do not thaw frozen Half & Half in the microwave.

When making a recipe that calls for Half and Half, it is essential to thoroughly whisk the liquid before adding it to the dish.

This will assist in preventing it from being curdled.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Half and Half

You have a number of choices available to you if you are seeking for an alternative to half-and-half.

It is possible to successfully substitute half-and-half with dairy-free milk, dairy-free cream, or even a mix of the two.

The following are the five most effective alternatives to half-and-half:

1 – Whole Milk + Heavy Cream

Two of the most common kinds of dairy products purchased are milk in its whole form and heavy cream.

Both of them have a smooth, velvety consistency, and a mouthwatering flavor.

On the other hand, since it contains a fraction of the amount of fat that heavy cream does, whole milk is a better option for those who are trying to limit their calorie consumption.

When whole milk is used in place of heavy cream, it is essential to keep in mind that the end product will not be as thick or as rich as the original.

It is possible that you may need to adjust the amount of milk called for in the recipe by a little amount to account for this.

On the other hand, in general, using whole milk instead of heavy cream is a fantastic alternative that may help you reduce calories without sacrificing any of the flavor.

2 – Whole Milk + Light Cream

When mixed, whole milk and light cream produce a pleasant and velvety product that may be used to a number of different culinary and culinary-related uses.

This combination produces a velvety texture that is wonderful for producing whipped cream or smoothies, and it also has a rich flavor that is suitable for adding to coffee or tea.

In addition, this mixture may be used in place of half-and-half in any recipes that call for that ingredient.

You may easily replace the half and half in your favorite recipes with an equal quantity of whole milk and light cream, and the resulting dish will still have that dish’s signature opulent taste and velvety texture.

3 – Low-Fat Milk + Heavy Cream

One of the most flexible dairy products, low-fat milk may be used in a wide range of culinary preparations.

Because it has a flavor that is not overpowering and a texture that is creamy, it is an excellent alternative for half and half.

The nutritional value of low-fat milk is identical to that of whole milk; the only difference is that it contains much less fat.

It is essential to use the same quantity of low-fat milk whenever Half & Half is replaced with another kind of milk.

This will guarantee that your dish comes out to be just as wonderful as it would be if you used half-and-half instead.

Therefore, the next time you are in the mood for a meal that is rich and creamy, instead of reaching for the heavy cream, grab the low-fat milk instead.

It’s possible that the deliciousness of it will surprise you.

4 – Whole Milk + Melted Butter

When combined, whole milk and melted butter produce a liquid that is both decadent and smooth, making it suitable for a wide range of culinary applications.

The mixture has a flavor that is just a touch sweet, and its consistency is really smooth.

It is crucial to remember to use the same ratio of whole milk to melted butter when making a substitution for Half & Half using whole milk and melted butter.

If the recipe asks for one cup of Half and Half, for instance, you may use one cup of whole milk and two teaspoons of melted butter in its place.

Coffee, tea, soups, sauces, and desserts may all benefit from the addition of whole milk and melted butter.

Because it makes baked goods more dense and moist, it is an excellent option for baking. It is particularly useful for making cakes and biscuits.

When combining whole milk and butter that has been melted, you need to wait until the combination has somewhat cooled before adding it to hot liquids or cooking instructions that call for uncooked eggs.

5 – Milk + Butter

When it comes to baking, two of the most important components are milk and butter.

Cookies, cakes, and pies may all benefit from the rich and creamy taste that is produced when these two ingredients are combined.

In addition, the use of milk and butter lends baked items a certain texture that just cannot be achieved with any other ingredients.

It is crucial to choose a milk with a greater fat level when replacing milk for Half and Half in recipes. Examples of milk with a higher fat content include whole milk and 2% milk.

This will assist to guarantee that the baked products you create have a great texture and retain their moisture.


In conclusion, there are several options available for those looking for alternatives to half-and-half.

When it comes to baking, you can’t go wrong with using either whole milk or low-fat milk, or even milk combined with butter.

The ideal replacements for coffee or tea are either whole milk combined with light cream or whole milk combined with heavy cream.

In addition, people who are trying to reduce the amount of calories they consume will find that low-fat milk is an excellent option.

There is a replacement for half-and-half available that will work well for you no matter what your requirements are.

Therefore, the next time you are in the kitchen, look for one of these alternatives so that you may continue to enjoy the same opulent taste and velvety consistency in your favorite meals.


What is the best substitute for half and half?

Alternatives That Are Half and Half

Simply mix three quarters of a cup of whole milk and one fourth of a cup of heavy cream in a measuring cup (aka whipping cream). Utilize this combination in the same manner that you would use half-and-half, such as stirring it into a cup of coffee or tea or churning it into homemade ice cream. For example, if you had half-and-half, you would use it.

How unhealthy is half and half?

Using half and half cream rather than full-fat cream is one simple approach to reduce the amount of saturated animal fat in your diet. However, there is quite a lot of sugar in it. Sugar is naturally present in milk, and your body may metabolize this sugar to produce energy. However, the extra sugars found in sugary beverages and fat-free half and half may cause weight gain in addition to dental concerns.

What is a healthy alternative to half & half in my coffee?

5 Best Alternatives To Half-And-Half In Your Coffee

  • Evaporated Milk.
  • Oat Milk.
  • Yogurt.
  • Coconut Milk.
  • Milk and Cornstarch will do.

What can I use instead of half and half or heavy cream?

The 10 Best Substitutes for Heavy Cream

  • Milk and butter. A simple and reliable alternative to heavy cream that can be used in the majority of recipes is a combination of milk and butter….
  • Milk made from soy beans and olive oil…
  • Cornstarch and milk are going to get you…
  • combined with butter and half-and-half…
  • Silken tofu and soy milk. …
  • Greek yogurt with milk. …
  • Evaporated milk. …
  • Cottage cheese and milk are both options.