The 5 Best Substitutes for Chile Caribe

5/5 - (2 votes)

Chile Caribe is a variety of chili pepper that is frequently utilized in Peruvian cooking. This chili pepper is also known as aji Amarillo.

Peppers are typically quite small and triangular in shape, and their color can range from bright red to orange.

Chili Caribe is frequently used as a seasoning and flavoring component in a wide variety of soups, stews, and sauces.

In addition to that, it can be added to salads or used as a garnish.

In this article, we will provide five of the best alternatives to Chile Caribe for you to consider if you are looking for an alternative.

So let’s get started.

What is Chile Caribe?

The islands of the Caribbean are the birthplace of the fiery sauce known as “Chile Caribe.”

The sauce is a combination of fresh chili peppers, tomatoes, and onions that have been blended together.

As a condiment for grilled meats, or as a dipping sauce for bread and crackers, it is used quite frequently.

Additionally, the sauce can be used to season stews and soups before serving them.

Because Chile Caribe is typically very spicy, it is essential to test its heat level before employing it on a large scale.

When it comes to the flavor, just a little bit of the sauce can go a very long way.

When deciding how much Chile Caribe to use in a dish, it is important to consider both the heat tolerance of the people who will be eating it and the other spices that will be included in the dish.

Chile Caribe is an adaptable sauce that can lend a bit of spiciness to a variety of dishes thanks to its robust flavor profile.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Chile Caribe

There are a few alternatives available to choose from in the event that you are looking for a replacement for Chile Caribe.

The following are the five most suitable alternatives to Chile Caribe:

1 – Pasilla Chile

The Pasilla chile is a type of pepper that is long and dark in color, and it has a flavor that is subdued and earthy.

You can find them dried or fresh, and they are frequently used in traditional Mexican cuisine.

When dried, pasilla chiles take on a slightly chewy texture and take on a flavor that is slightly sweet.

The flavor of fresh pasilla chilies is somewhat reminiscent of fruit.

The Pasilla chile is frequently utilized in the preparation of sauces and soups.

In addition to that, you may utilize them as an alternative to Chile Caribe.

There is a kind of chili pepper called chile caribe that is indigenous to the Caribbean.

Flavor-wise and in terms of the amount of heat it packs, it is quite comparable to the pasilla chile.

The primary distinction between these two peppers is that Chile Caribe has a more subtly sweet flavor than Pasilla Chile does.

It is essential to keep this distinction in mind whenever you make a substitution for Chile Caribe using pasilla chile.

The dish will have a flavor that is slightly more earthy if Pasilla chile is used, while Chile Caribe will add a touch of sweetness to the dish.

2 – Cascabel Chilie

The name “cascabel” refers to the Spanish word for “rattle,” which is where this particular variety of chili pepper gets its name.

” These peppers are on the smaller side and round, with a surface that is wrinkly and a color that is deep red.

The flesh of the cascabel chile is paper-thin and extremely spicy, with a heat that gradually builds up and lingers on the tongue after each bite.

Cascabel chiles, before being put to use in a dish, are almost always roasted first and then ground into a powder.

In any recipe that calls for chili pepper, you can substitute this powder for the chili pepper instead.

In addition, the whole peppers can be substituted in recipes calling for Chile Caribe to achieve the same flavor.

If you need to make a substitution, use one cascabel chile for every two Caribe peppers that the recipe calls for.

This will guarantee that each serving of your dish has the same amount of heat.

3 – Guajillo Pepper

Guajillo is a type of chili pepper that is commonly used in traditional Mexican cooking.

It has a flavor that is sweet and fruity and a level of heat that is mild to medium.

It is more common to use dried and ground guajillo peppers, but fresh guajillo peppers can also be used.

In addition to being a common component of mole dishes, they are frequently incorporated into the preparation of sauces and salsas.

When making a substitution for Chile Caribe with guajillo peppers, it is imperative that the heat level be taken into consideration.

Because Guajillo peppers are not as fiery as Chile Caribe peppers, you might require additional peppers in order to achieve the desired level of heat in your dish.

In addition, the fruity flavor of the guajillo peppers will come through more clearly than the smoky flavor of the Chile Caribe peppers.

If you want a chili pepper that has a milder heat and a sweeter flavor overall, guajillo peppers are a good alternative to Chile Caribe. Guajillo peppers are available in most grocery stores.

4 – Ancho Pepper

A poblano pepper that has been dried and smoked is called an ancho chili pepper.

It has a pleasant taste that is sweet and just slightly tangy, and it has a smoky aroma.

The texture has a leathery appearance, and the consistency is slightly chewy.

Chili peppers from the ancho variety are frequently used in traditional Mexican cuisine, particularly in enchiladas, tamales, and mole sauce.

It is also possible to use them to make ristras, which are dried strings of chili peppers that are used as decorations. Ristras can be made using these.

When using an ancho chili pepper in place of chile caribe, the ratio of one pepper to two tablespoons of chile caribe should be maintained.

5 – Mulato Pepper

There is a variety of chili pepper known as the Mulato pepper, which is a member of the Capsicum annuum species.

The Nahuatl word for “black” is where it gets its name, which is derived from the fact that it is a common ingredient in Mexican cuisine.

Small and heart-shaped, mulato peppers have a color that is somewhere between red and brown.

They are typically used in savory dishes, despite the fact that they have a sweet flavor that is reminiscent of chocolate and coffee.

In certain recipes, Chile Caribe peppers can be replaced with Mulato peppers instead.

Chile Caribe peppers are comparable in size and shape to standard bell peppers, but their flavor is noticeably hotter.

When making a substitution, use one pepper from the Mulato variety for every two peppers from the Chile Caribe variety that are called for in the recipe.


In conclusion, there are a wide variety of other kinds of chili peppers that can be used in place of Chile Caribe.

When looking for a suitable replacement, it is essential to take into consideration both the level of heat and the flavor.

Chile Caribe can be replaced with cascabel chiles, guajillo peppers, ancho peppers, or mulato peppers. These are the best peppers to use in its place.

Alternatives to the chili peppers used in Chile Caribe include smoked paprika and chipotle powder, in addition to the chili peppers themselves.


What are Caribe peppers?

The Caribe chile is a small, pale yellow pepper that gets its name from the indigenous people of the Caribbean islands and is pronounced cah-REE-bay. They are a variety of wax peppers that are yellow in color and originated in the Caribbean. During the time of Christopher Columbus, they became increasingly popular throughout Central America.

How hot is a Caribe pepper?

The Caribbean Red Pepper, also known as the King of Hot, is possibly one of the hottest peppers ever discovered by humankind. This will get your endorphins going. Caribbean Red peppers have between 350,000 and 400,000 Scoville units of heat, making them significantly more painful to eat than Habanero peppers.

What can you substitute for chili peppers?

The following 5 peppers work well instead of red chilli pepper in recipes:

  • Serrano Pepper. The serrano pepper, which is picked when it is still green, has a higher level of heat than the red chili pepper.
  • Jalapeno Pepper. …
  • Cayenne Pepper. …
  • Pequin Chilli Pepper. …
  • Tien Tsin Chilli Pepper.

What does Caribe pepper taste like?

The region of Southern Chihuahua in Mexico is where the caribe pepper first appeared. In the more mountainous parts of this state in Mexico, you can find them growing. Their heat is not particularly intense, but it burns quickly and leaves behind a flavor that is distinctively sweet.

What is green chile Caribe?

Green chile that has been dried and flaked, along with the seeds that it was grown from in Hatch, New Mexico, the Chile Capital of the World. Green Chile Caribe Flakes are typically combined with hot water to form a paste. Green Chile Caribe is frequently used as the foundation for many different Chilean recipes. Try some of the Dried Whole Chile Pods if you want to crush the chilies on your own.